I don't buy into the fact that it is "your" morality that you bring to the game. I am playing a role, and as such I make decisions that make sense for that character. I am not a werewolf. I cannot turn into a 9-foot-tall man bat. But my character is or can do those things. As such, his belief system is not my own. No one tried to have me executed; I play Skyrim, Oblivion, Fallout 3, New Vegas, Bioshock, etc without the risk of personal harm. Furthermore, the harm inflicted on a series of algorithms that represent NPCs within the game is in no way representative of my views towards people. Therefore, I reject the implication that people who may roll an evil 'toon are closet psychos.
Oh, I do agree with you. However, some folks are much better at RP than others. While I realize I'm not a buff psycho killer in real life as I play in the game, I end up with this weird dichotomy that I have certain bigotries towards behaviours (i.e. thievery in my case) that I am unable to completely suspend my own moral structure for the sake of RP. Perhaps, if I spent many hours on RP, I would get better at it and be able to better seperate, but I am, at this point, still a slave to my own emotions and cannot disassociate myself completely in order to be totally immersive.
I hope you don't think I was implying that playing evil made you a closet psycho. I certainly didn't mean that implication at all. As a matter of fact, my character is pretty psycho. No problem w/cannibalism re Namia or murding innocent people for a reward (DB, Mehrune, Bothia, Namia, Molag Bol, et al.) or slaughtering countless Foreswarn and Bandits and Fullmer. My character is greedy, trigger happy, bloodthirsty, short tempered, violent, generous, caring, charitable, helpful and patient. While I may not be all of those things, some I am.
I think my point was that, for many of us, particularly those of us that are newer or do not spend a lot of time in RP, we do tend to bring our own belief systems (whether willing or not) in to our RP, particularly in heavy RP games like Skyrim. You, on the other hand seem to have a great strength in RP and being able to immerse completely in to the characters. I admire that and hope some day to be able to be so skilled.