Meh, I'm torn from both sides. It's just the thought of how humanity was created.
If we have the audacity to think, believe, pray, right in different ways, even though we are still classified in scientific terms as Homo sapean (sorry for spelling) it just shows you, we were made like this for a REASON.
so do to all these points given out between vampire rights, thoughts, beliefs, including the dawnguards, they are either these in said equation of opinions:
EQUALLY FAIR, since humans have the tendency to argue until their dying breath (sorry but I've seen this too many times. But it is good! Fighting for what you think is good. To a fault anyway. If you're swearing and stabbing, I think that draws the line LOL). Or, these accusations on both sides are NEUTRAL. Or in other words, they snuff each other out.
Since humans are carbon based and are part of science, it doesn't mean we ask questions that are indeed, law. Furthermore, we came up with rules that corrispond to what we have discovered to be law, and our own opinions. And still we argue.
So saying that all vampires are evil, is invalid. Saying all dawnguard are good, is invalid. They are scientifically invalid questions and there are no correct answers.
My fanfic that I'm going to write will dictate this fact. Even animals can have human like nature, but like some people have said, they aren't humans. Vampires have a desease, yes. Some deseases in the real world alter thinking, interaction, beliefs, and just well being. For the dawnguard, anger, hatred, and general dislike for something that yes indeed, can be helped, they have the tendency to judge. But do they have the right?
Stay with me here. Yes, vampires have the ability to go to that one guy to become cured. But if in the real world, we can do what we want, when we want, only our beliefs, culture, and law holding us back, the same thing applies to the Vampire race.
If they want to be vampiric, that is fine. So is it right to slaughter an innocent if they hate but love being a vampire? Same with werewolves. Do they have the right to be judged? Yes, since they are big, and fluffy and hairy. And kinda scary looking. But some of them didn't ask for it.
For those two, vampire and werewolf kind, there are ones that are sinful and tend to slaughter. Yes, Dawnguard do then have a right. But that does not ALL make them kin of demons and such. Dawnguard just have much sinful pleasures and rights as vampires and werewolves. Because they were human before.
I've said this many times before: We are all equal, but so different, so unique it's like we are all different species. So we both have rights and no rights to judge. Depending on situation, everyones history make up, and phycological well being.
Severus Alucard my character, is a vampire lord. Although he dislikes feeding on humans he only does it when it's absolutely necessary. Serana *points out* blood potions and hands them out.
If you feel guilty about killing someone, if you have this nagging feeling of guilt or self hatred for what you've done, but trying to move on and better yourself, do you still deserve to be killed? Severus understood some of the Dawnguard weren't always cruel to vampires. Ignard (or what's his face) didn't imediately attack Serana during the Dawnguard side of the quest. Good example.
About the deserving of death, the Dawnguard sees the vampires as a threat. But they can't judge. You cannot, I repeat, can NOT know someone till you know yourself. And even then, you cannot ever know yourself. Everyone is unpredictable. Which leads to the fact vampires can be unpredictable yes, but so can Dawnguard.
Vampires and werewolves, trolls and dragons, they all have feelings. I've seen everyone not hating on Paarthurnax! Even though once upon a time he helped his brother. But he overcame that and helped humans in Alduins destruction. Same with vampires.
Although yes, not all vampires are good, and some can be ruthless, so can Dawnguard and humans everywhere. I know this is just a game and all, but this happens in real life too. Severus Alucard had a bad childhood. As you can see from his character card (in my signature). He didn't want to hurt dawnguard, for perhaps they misunderstood.. But he had a choice, he hated the choice of killing the dawnguard, but it was to be killed, or defend and kill. Of course he always gives the chance for the to turn tail and run: "I may be a killer, but I am by no means, a monster."
Sorry for the long post XD and sorry if I offened anyone.
