What faction are you in?

[raido KASAI]

I think it's time to draw a line and pick a side.

So which is it?

cake?

or pie?

 

[raido KASAI]

You can have some feelings for both, but like stormcloaks and imperials, you can only pick one....

 

[JoeReese]

Hmm...both are wonderful and delicious, but cake is easier for me to bake from scratch, so cake.

 

[raido KASAI]

but pie is versatile because you have desserts and yummy meals like chicken pot pie
[/devil's advocate]

 

[Kalin of High Rock]

Does the blanket term "pie" also include Pizza?

 

[raido KASAI]

Does the blanket term "pie" also include Pizza?

indeed. that's a pie

 

[Irishman]

I hear meat pies (chunky steak, bacon, mince, chunky chicken... or a micture of those) arnt as common everywhere else as it is in Australia. Im not a dessert pie kinda guy, but I absolutely love a good quality meat pie (steak n Bacon... OMG!!) soooo.... do they count ?

 

[JoeReese]

Does the blanket term "pie" also include Pizza?

Oh schnap...I didn't think about that. Can I change?

 

[Lucid]

My kitchen towels have pictures of a cheeky 50's housewife with the caption "Who wants pie?" What's not to love about pie? It's more difficult to make than cake, but offers better ROI. Also I don't care much for frosting.

Ill just leave this here as "evidence" Hyperbole and a half - Cake vs. Pie#mce_temp_url#

 

[raido KASAI]

Does the blanket term "pie" also include Pizza?

Oh schnap...I didn't think about that. Can I change?

Yes, turn to the dark side, we have pie.

Of course some may call you a desserter because of it

 

[raido KASAI]

For the record, cheesecake is actually a pie. It's an open-faced tart, has a crust....

 

[raido KASAI]

I hear meat pies (chunky steak, bacon, mince, chunky chicken... or a micture of those) arnt as common everywhere else as it is in Australia. Im not a dessert pie kinda guy, but I absolutely love a good quality meat pie (steak n Bacon... OMG!!) soooo.... do they count ?

It's a pie isn't it? Of course it counts

 

[Daelon DuLac]

But no blueberry pie... Yuck.

Oh, and I'll eat cake as long as it's not chocolate!

and brownies.... mmmmm.... brownies....

 

[Irishman]

My kitchen towels have pictures of a cheeky 50's housewife with the caption "Who wants pie?" What's not to love about pie? It's more difficult to make than cake, but offers better ROI. Also I don't care much for frosting.

Ill just leave this here as "evidence" Hyperbole and a half - Cake vs. Pie#mce_temp_url#

I only like cake, If I get the F@CKING FROSTING ROSE !!!

...and since I dont always get it, pie easily wins

 

[ZeroDragon]

I love pie !!! Many different ones, but they're all pie.

 

[cjclemens]

Theres really only two kinds of pie that I like - hot or cold.

 

[mattizcool]

Muffins.

 

[Lucid]

My kitchen towels have pictures of a cheeky 50's housewife with the caption "Who wants pie?" What's not to love about pie? It's more difficult to make than cake, but offers better ROI. Also I don't care much for frosting.

Ill just leave this here as "evidence" Hyperbole and a half - Cake vs. Pie#mce_temp_url#

I only like cake, If I get the F@CKING FROSTING ROSE !!!

...and since I dont always get it, pie easily wins

Proving the point "The act of decorating a cake can polarize it and cause a dangerously uneven distribution of frosting, leading to discord and animosity during serving time. "

 

[raido KASAI]

Theres really only two kinds of pie that I like - hot or cold.

Those both are good. I also enjoy room temperature if it's made right

 

[raido KASAI]

My kitchen towels have pictures of a cheeky 50's housewife with the caption "Who wants pie?" What's not to love about pie? It's more difficult to make than cake, but offers better ROI. Also I don't care much for frosting.

Ill just leave this here as "evidence" Hyperbole and a half - Cake vs. Pie#mce_temp_url#

I only like cake, If I get the F@CKING FROSTING ROSE !!!

...and since I dont always get it, pie easily wins

Proving the point "The act of decorating a cake can polarize it and cause a dangerously uneven distribution of frosting, leading to discord and animosity during serving time. "

Plus, while I enjoy a pie with toppings, there being nothing but bare crust on the top is not a deal breaker. There are some good non-frosted cake choices, but there is a significant enjoyment different with frosting and without.

Some cakes are simply a good delivery vehicle for tasty frosting