I'm surprised so many people were creeped out by the Innocence Lost mission. I felt sorry for the kid but wasn't sure if it was all an act. I went to the Orphanage and just listened, unsure of how to approach the situation. As soon as she started telling the children about being beaten and then forced them to stand there whilst she told them how nobody loved any of them I was just disgusted.
Basically, I walked up to her casually, gutted the old crone like a fish and just walked out of there.
When the kids started cheering, I thought it was actually kind of heartwarming, I felt like it was true justice. No one should be allowed to maltreat innocent children like that.
As for what did creep me out, well, I'm still new to the game, you understand. But thus far, what has really frightened me is my first encounter with a Spriggan. I was walking through the rural areas and attempting to get to civilisation. Upon reaching a stone archway, one of the damned beasts rose from under the earth and began attacking me. The fact that it kept transforming into a swarm of insects and could heal itself completely just freaked me out. It's weird, but I never feel comfortable wandering around the farms and ruins now. Animals I can handle, but these so-called 'guardians' of nature terrify me.
Moreso than the Vampires, even.