Skyrim / Oblivion : Dark Brotherhood Falkreath Sanctuary vs Cheydinhal Sanctuary

[VolenKiller]

Skyrim's Dark Brotherhood Falkreath Sanctuary versus Oblivion's Dark Brotherhood Cheydinhal Sanctuary. Who would win? please tell me your opinion. I say Cheydinhal by far. My sister says Falkreath.

 

[Mikea]

Falkreath, cos it's got that vampire kid. That means she can't die

 

[VolenKiller]

Haha i totally disagree. Cheydinhal has a vampire too. And 2 Shadowscales. And an orc badass. and an awesome kahjiit mage. and some other normal assassins.

 

[Mikea]

No what i mean is that children can't die in skyrim

 

[Mikea]

or be hurt at all

 

[VolenKiller]

Oh well I mean not game wise I mean legit all out "real life" combat

 

[Mikea]

Then Cheydinhal

 

[Kane Minehunter]

Cheydinhal by miles, the people were alot cooler aswell. Is it just me, but did you find all the guilds on Skyrim abit lacking in somthing? Oblivions were just longer, and better in my opinion.

 

[VolenKiller]

Totally agree. College of Winterhold was a total disapointment. Companions was okay.

 

[Kane Minehunter]

Just finished Dark Brotherhood, while your playing it it's great. Full of twists, cinematics and such. But its so short it's unreal. Same with the College, like you say, its a let down. I have not done the Companions yet, so we will see.

 

[VolenKiller]

Indeed. Dark brotherhood was so crappy compared to oblivions dark brotherhood, I did the quest to slaughter them.

 

[A.Auditore]

I would say that the oblivion brotherhood would tear the skyrim brotherhood a new void

 

[Gandalf The Boss]

It was ALOT more interesting in Oblivion because there was so much more history with all the members. In Skyrim the quests was great but you never really felt like part of the family like you did in Oblivion.

 

[A.Auditore]

I would say that the oblivion brotherhood would tear the skyrim brotherhood a new void

and with that in mind (next day lol) if for some reason the oblivion brotherhood failed the BlackHand would step in and again "rip them a new void" speaking of which why doesnt skyrim have the black hand in it???

 

[HEFFAY]

and with that in mind (next day lol) if for some reason the oblivion brotherhood failed the BlackHand would step in and again "rip them a new void" speaking of which why doesnt skyrim have the black hand in it???

Skyrim didn't have a black hand because it wasn't legit, Astrid was in charge not a Listener... It wasn't until the Night Mother arrived that they started getting thier plops together, and even then Astrid tried to set you up...

Oblivion took place when the dark brotherhood was at thier hieght, skyrim comes when they are on thier last leg...

That's why Cheydinhal would win, they wouldn't have been willing to 'make a deal' with anyone, they would have told the imperials what's up.

I'm gonna break down by character, (my own opinion) using 'cs' to stand for Cheydinhal Sanctuary, and 'fs' to stand for falkreath's sanctuary.

Ocheeva would kill Astrid easily (cs-1, fs-0), That Orc would go up against Astrid's Hubby the werewolf (tie). the Falkreath's Shadow Scale was more badass than taneeva of Chedynhall (cs-1, fs-1), Nazir and the Khajit would have been a pretty good battle (tie), and the Cheydinhal vampire was better than Falkreath's (cs-2, fs-1). Cheydinhal also had Lucien Lachance as thier listener, falkreath didn't have one until you (cs-3, fs-1), and they had two pets, the skeleton and the rat but falkreath's spider would have beaten them, Cheydinhal also had that girl antionette maria, so they win that one by default, (cs-4 fs-2 w/2 ties) ...

Also, Cicero would have fought for Cheydinhal had a battle occured...

Grand total = Cheydinhal wins...


p.s. You could buy stuff in cheydinhall, like spells, weapons, and lock picks... they were better equipt.

 

[Necromis]

I think you have a problem with your logics on why one faction or the other would win. Remember something. These groups are not the blades or the companions. They are both Assassin Guilds. Thus there should never be a straight up fight between them. May I suggest you rethink your answers based on stealth kills, poisoned meals, arrow snipers and slit throats. The little girl vampire IMO is actually a very high point for the Skyrim Faction as her innocence appearance leads to more under estimation and assuming she is not an assassin.

 

[HEFFAY]

I think you have a problem with your logics on why one faction or the other would win. Remember something. These groups are not the blades or the companions. They are both Assassin Guilds. Thus there should never be a straight up fight between them. May I suggest you rethink your answers based on stealth kills, poisoned meals, arrow snipers and slit throats. The little girl vampire IMO is actually a very high point for the Skyrim Faction as her innocence appearance leads to more under estimation and assuming she is not an assassin.

Necromis I disagree, Whether or not it was an all out fight... it doesn't change the fact that the cheydinhal sanctuary outnumbered, and was better equipt, than falkreath's. Cheydinhal's leadership was stronger willed and more organized. Cheydinhal cheydinhal had the strength to to operate in a major city, not hidden in the woods.

 

[Necromis]

Oh I wasn't saying that Falkreath would win based on my logics. Just that the rules change with it. Do you think that the better organized and larger group had better sneaks and killers? If so how do you feel it would play out?

 

[VolenKiller]

I agree partially with you HEFFAY . Necromis i have not thought about it that way, but still no doubt Cheydinhal would win. And not to mention i didn't like Skyrim's armor at all. Original was wayyyyy better

 

[Kane Minehunter]

I know right Volen, With the skyrim shroud armour on skyrim everyone looks like sandpeople of start wars. Really? Oblivion was just better, apart from the helemet, which was a bit tight..