Imperials or Stormcloaks, what one?

  • Welcome to Skyrim Forums! Register now to participate using the 'Sign Up' button on the right. You may now register with your Facebook or Steam account!

Rimfaxe96

Well-Known Member
I'm just going to throw my newest findings in here.

Thongvor: "How goes the trade in and out of the city?"
Reburrus: "Very well, Thongvor. With the Stormcloaks here to help, the Silver-Blood family control nearly every route in and out of the city."
Yngvar: "Except the ones attacked by Forsworn."
Reburrus: "Well yes, of course you had to go and mention that."
Thongvor: "The Forsworn aren't our real concern, defeating the Imperials and making sure we keep control of this city is."
Reburrus: "Yes, Thongvor."

Thongvor: "Reburrus, I need you to draft a letter to Ulfric requesting more men."
Yngvar: "Ha! About time we got some more muscle in this city."
Reburrus: "Thongvor, do you really think that's wise? I mean, King Ulfric is such a busy man, and there are so many areas of Skyrim to protect."
Thongvor: "Whose side are you on, Reburrus? I'm not worried about Skyrim, I'm worried about the Reach. Specifically, the part of the Reach we're standing on."
Reburrus: "Yes, Thongvor. I'll draft the letter immediately."

It appears the Silver-Blood family is the Stormcloak-equivalent of the Blackbriar Family, only that the Blackbriars at least don't support a group of desperate people who in turn slaughter civilians.
 

LegateFasendil

Imperial Legate
No, no, no. Just... stop. An Empire is not one Province. This is not the Empire State of Cyrodil. You have to understand Imperialism and the Thalmor want to liquidate man's Imperialism so then it would be their turn to rule as much as possible to rule in Tamriel.

If the Empire loses Skyrim, it's destroyed:

- Logistically (Can't maintain supply lines to few remaining Imperial holdings)
- Politically (No provincial politician will back a weak Emperor / Council, esp if said Empire can't re-enforce them)
- Economically (Economically speaking the Empire would be toast without Skyrim and Skyrim's agriculture will suffer without the Empire)
- Militarily (By contradiction I can prove you wrong. The only reason the Empire survived the war was because of the Nord Warrior and Breton Battlemage Legions, therefore, it must be an Empire to continue to hold Highrock and Skyrim, where these soldiers train from)
- The WGC will become a Religion in Cyrodil because there will then be no hope of saving anyone from the WGC outside of Skyrim. Cyrodil and Highrock will be on their own, on sep sides of Tamriel and at the mercy of the Thalmor and their allies. You'll be liberating Skyrim from the WGC but damming the people in Cyrodil and Highrock from having any chance to unite against the Thalmor. Those states will, without the Empire, could be absorbed by the Thalmor or will live in the shadow of kingdom come with no hope of rescue and the death of the Empire kills any hope of real unity.
Your Empire is dead anyway, that's one of the reasons I and so many others fought in the first place. Either way your Empire is dead. And I prefer Skyrim my homeland to not be dragged down with it!



I hear what you're saying Mikulas, but the Thalmor want you to be free, it supports their long term goals in Skyrim. They don't want the Stormcloaks victorious but they fear an Imperial victory even more.

Surely the Empire is not so dead after all if the Thalmor fear it coming out the winner in this fight. It's a chance but it's not a chance the Thalmor want to take, says so in the Dossier.

I'll take my chances :)
 

Mikulas Black-Blade

The Cave Bear
No, no, no. Just... stop. An Empire is not one Province. This is not the Empire State of Cyrodil. You have to understand Imperialism and the Thalmor want to liquidate man's Imperialism so then it would be their turn to rule as much as possible to rule in Tamriel.

If the Empire loses Skyrim, it's destroyed:

- Logistically (Can't maintain supply lines to few remaining Imperial holdings)
- Politically (No provincial politician will back a weak Emperor / Council, esp if said Empire can't re-enforce them)
- Economically (Economically speaking the Empire would be toast without Skyrim and Skyrim's agriculture will suffer without the Empire)
- Militarily (By contradiction I can prove you wrong. The only reason the Empire survived the war was because of the Nord Warrior and Breton Battlemage Legions, therefore, it must be an Empire to continue to hold Highrock and Skyrim, where these soldiers train from)
- The WGC will become a Religion in Cyrodil because there will then be no hope of saving anyone from the WGC outside of Skyrim. Cyrodil and Highrock will be on their own, on sep sides of Tamriel and at the mercy of the Thalmor and their allies. You'll be liberating Skyrim from the WGC but damming the people in Cyrodil and Highrock from having any chance to unite against the Thalmor. Those states will, without the Empire, could be absorbed by the Thalmor or will live in the shadow of kingdom come with no hope of rescue and the death of the Empire kills any hope of real unity.
Your Empire is dead anyway, that's one of the reasons I and so many others fought in the first place. Either way your Empire is dead. And I prefer Skyrim my homeland to not be dragged down with it!



I hear what you're saying Mikulas, but the Thalmor want you to be free, it supports their long term goals in Skyrim. They don't want the Stormcloaks victorious but they fear an Imperial victory even more.

Surely the Empire is not so dead after all if the Thalmor fear it coming out the winner in this fight. It's a chance but it's not a chance the Thalmor want to take, says so in the Dossier.

I'll take my chances :)

They don't want us free, sure they may favor a Stormcloak victory because we have less supplies, But the Thalmor want us to be their Slaves, their puppets. I'm taking my chances as well.
Good luck friend. May Kyne guide you.
 

Raijin

A Mage that loves a Templar
You do realize that a rebellion is nothing without a cause, right? The Thalmor are indirectly aiding the rebellion by being there to be the cause.

Have you listened to your own buddies in the rebellion?

Why is it worded the way it is? It makes no sense if it is to tell that the way simply needs to keep going. It makes sense if they are afraid of a united empire, which would also explain why they simply want to avoid the rebellion winning, rather than show any fear of them.

Well if that's true, by what you said, then the Thalmor are also indirectly aiding the Imperial Legion and the Empire by creating the Stormcloak rebellion in the first place by banning the worship of Talos. They gave the Thalmor what they want, and now the Thalmor is sitting back watching the dire consequences unraveled.

Yes I've listen to my buddies in the rebellion... Do you lend them your ear and listen to their plea? What their fighting for is legit.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000c348f

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000e1b22

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x0005b41d
 

DrunkenMage

Intoxicated Arch-Mage
The dossier also mentions "indirect aid to the Stormcloaks must be carefully managed" Exactly what does that mean? How is the Thalmor indirectly aiding the Stormcloaks? Is their any evidence without voicing an opinion that truly backs this up? Because of all the time that I've spent playing on this game I could not find a lore or a journal that says that the Stormcloaks are indirectly being aided by the Thalmor? I can't accept the Dossier as accurate information considering the fact that theirs nothing that indicates that the Thalmor are financially support the Stormcloaks.

"We've been trying to catch Ulfric since the war started, but he always seemed to slip through our fingers... like he knew we were coming." - Hadvar

We know they've been trying to keep Ulfric alive.

Indirect aid, not direct aid. Financially supporting the rebellion would be direct aid, but their increased presence and strict enforcement of the Talos Ban is one of the key motivations of people joining Ulfric's rebellion. Listening to Stormcloak conversations at camps, they mention the Thalmor's actions recently are the reason some are under Ulfric's banner.

"When we destroy the rebellion, perhaps the Thalmor will call off their damned inquisitions. It's just making things worse." - Rikke

"I put in to be stationed here to keep an eye on the Thalmor. I've a feeling they're behind this unrest in Skyrim." - Fasendil

There is a lot of information that backs up the Dossier, looking for that smoking gun that will destroy why people should side with the Stormcloaks won't be found.

It is the reason many in this thread support the rebellion? The Thalmor going around arresting Talos worshipers, their recent increased presence is what many of you use in your arguments. The Thalmor are your big motivator, same with many Nords.

Why do you think Ulfric had such little support in his cause over the Talos Ban when the Thalmor were only minor in Skyrim?
 

Mikulas Black-Blade

The Cave Bear
Ebony Warrior is dead and the Greybeards will not fight in a war.
The Greybeards gave aid for war before. They constantly summon the Ash King and hes practically Unstoppable.

I don't remember what reasons the book gave, it was Colin's test. Not that everyone has the exact same test, it probably varies on the person.
Good enough, I suppose.

Why would you tell them he's a Thalmor? They're not Penitus Oculatus yet, they've been given an order to carry out a task. Being observed on how they do it.
Well like I said he finds that he's an old defenseless man who is quoted for suspicious acts and then he decides whether or not he can kill him.

I don't think there is a "kicked off the Penitus Oculatus" more likely you'd be killed.
So they kill you if you don't pass. Well that's fair.

Others have brought it up, across several threads on this forum.
Guess Ill have to check that out.

One is a revolution, the other is a Civil War.
It's not so black and white. A lot of people stayed loyal to the crown. They fought along side the British or aided them in the war so there was a possibility of Brother vs. Brother.

Small number of local people, majority of support came when Ulfric killed Torygg.
A large majority of support came from the Boston Tea Party and the Boston "Massacre".

Half the country was against the American Revolution?
More like a third actually. You see, 1/3 wanted revolution, while another 1/3 stayed loyal to the crown, and another 1/3 didn't give a damn as long as their limbs were still in tact :D

The Nords won't fight guerrilla warfare, the Stormcloaks after the war plan to create nine different armies under the Jarls. Which given the nature of Nords, often doesn't work out well for them. Cause the Jarls bicker a lot, Hold wars are a common theme Pre-Empire days in Skyrim.
Doesn't mean they aren't going to organize ambushes, kill at night, be in general sneaky. The Stormcloaks, and Nords in general, excel at Raids.

If the Stormcloaks were fighting the Dominion in Skyrim, the Empire would be destroyed. Who would aid them anyway? The Dunmer have their own problems and haven't recovered. Hammerfell is devastated and High Rock is famous for political bickering.
Hammerfell isn't going to sit this war out. Morrowind seems okay, they're still recovering but if they have their quarrels with the Thalmor and The Empire.

They Dominion in TESO was building inside Valenwood, why would the Thalmor of the Fourth Era fear what their predecessors didn't?
But do we know if they were using Materials from Valenwood or not. Its perfectly okay to build in Valenwood just so long as you don't harm the Forest.

No it wasn't. There were Khajiit insurgents operating inside the Empire, over what they considered the stealing of their land. Elsweyr isn't impossible to control, the Khajiit are merely client states. They didn't fight for the Aldmeri during the Great War.
Let me repeat: the relationship between the Khajiit and the Empire was awful while the relationship between The Thalmor and the Khajiit is good. Relationship with the citizenry is important.

No she isn't, not anymore at least. She's been dead for over six hundred years, I think whatever influence she had, fell away by now.
I suppose so, just throwing it out there.

12,000 men? You got those stats from? I'm not saying it is all good, people die in war. Thousands on both sides. But calling Titus II's tactics crap because people died is foolish, his tactics are what won the Imperial City back and eliminated the main Aldmeri army.
le·giona unit of 3,000–6,000 men in the ancient Roman army.
As you know the Imperials are based off of the Romans so this should be the same or similar. I'm calling his tactics crap because they were literally just: Charge from all sides and hope we win the city back.

No, he gets a city.
And loses one, or two.

Many great Mages have come out of Skyrim.
Name Five and how many of them were Nords?

Race doesn't mean anything.
In the Elder Scrolls it means a lot.

There isn't separated Legions? Look at Morrowind, the Legion there had Imperials, Nords, Orcs. Look at Skyrim's Legions filled with Imperials, Redguards, Nords, Bretons etc.
In battle they separate what you're good at based on race. Hence why Jonna led a legion of mostly Nords so they could be the pushing power.

Legions in different provinces may have larger numbers of the native race, that is natural because there are simply more of them in that province.
Obviously.

The Legion doesn't separate on race.
No but they separate based on what people are good at. and The Legions Jonna commanded were mostly Nords because most Nords are good at a similar thing. Force and Ferocity.

Not too many, many Stormcloaks are one handed.p
And many are Two Handed it would seem we have come to an Impasse.

Actually she doesn't say soldiers, my mistake. "They ended up sacking the Imperial City. I was there, blasting apart young Elven men and women with Fireballs and Lightning Bolts."

Being naturally gifted doesn't make them the best. They still have to work at it.
Well then that's different. Being Elven definitely means they have a head start. Of course they have a natural weakness to Magic.

They're considered the best because they trained, it was even theorized they invented the bow.

Being born Bosmer, doesn't make you a great archer. You have to work on skills, you're not born the best.
Again, it definitely gives you a head start, tell me, How many Bosmer warriors do you see on a daily basis.

Actually the quality of Imperial Battlemages was extremely good.
I'm sure they were

No. Because I don't think like that, in-game doesn't mean it is like that in lore. Every race, even cultures today are generalized. But not every Bosmer is an archer, just like not every American has a gun.
But most Bosmer are and Most Americans do.

I'm not saying that every race doesn't have their famous traits they're credited with. I'm saying just because you are that race, it doesn't mean you're gifted with the ability to wield a sword or shoot a bow. Swordsmanship requires training, same as marksmanship. People in TES aren't born with it in lore, except Altmer on being magically gifted, they are born with that reserve of magic. But it doesn't make them the best Mages.[/quote]
Actually Redguards are naturally gifted and Nords are naturally resistant to Cold and Magical Frost as well as being Naturally Fierce in battle and Dunmer are naturally gifted in Destruction Magic as well as being immune to Fire The List goes on Drunken these are not stats this is in-game and out of game Lore.

There are roads. The Aldmeri fought the Legions in their coup of Valenwood, they did attack and there were small battles. It isn't like Valenwood hasn't ever been attacked before.
Oh yeah it was attacked before and it was pretty grizzly for the attacking side.

"Don't you Nords put any stock in your own traditions? I thought the Moot chose the king." - Tullius, Jagged Crown quest
I bet you he didn't know that until Rikke told him

He knows it now.
Because Rikke told him.

Well Rikke tells him, so he does know.
After an entire war only NOW does he know where Nords go when they die.

Fighting style and intentions? How do you get that from 'Sovngarde'. Is that word supposed to mean a certain form of fighting or weapon usage?
It means they're relentless and don't fear death. When a Nord Dies he goes to Blissful Sovngarde. Where you do nothing but fight, drink sing and eat. Its every Nords dream!

No pl***. You really think they care? They believe they're Gods.
Well then why didn't they just destroy the White Gold Tower while they had it for 30 days

You're invading them, good luck.
And good luck with yours, hope they don't kill you to gruesomely. At least a Fire Explosion Spell is a relatively quick death.

It was a big battle, six days of continuous fighting. You think Tiber never lost soldiers? In fact Tiber Septim lost an entire Legion in a single ambush.
Well then boo on him, that was Tiber Septim the man, I worship Talos, Ysmir, The Dragon of the North.

Titus wasn't captured, and it took three years for the Aldmeri to sack the Imperial City.
I was talking about Ulfric but again, whatever.

What? Legions from Skyrim were fighting in Cyrodill for awhile. Ulfric was captured before the Imperial City fell.
What are you saying. I'm saying Ulfric wasn't a Legate and your over there talking about how Ulfric was captured before the Imperial city fell.

Also, what are you even on about? He didn't foresee trouble when trying to surround the main Aldmeri Dominion army? The Nord Legions weren't hit hard during the six days until the last of battle when the Aldmeri tried to retreat.

Those two counter attacks were slow, and not at once.
And he didn't foresee them. Y'know for a the great tactician Titus claims to be its hard to believe he just wouldn't know there were Soldiers camped in Bravil and Skingrad.

It doesn't mean the creatures weren't documented. You think some random creature stands a chance against the entire Imperial army? Every province is home to various creatures, didn't stop armies.
Basilisks might be a problem. how about Griffons, Werevultures.

Thousands of soldiers vs random creature. I wonder who will win?
Who's to say there will be one random creature, How about ten or twenty how well are you going to fight against 20 griffons or twenty Basilisks.

Valenwood is a forest and it has roads.
Well you best use those to the best of your ability, because one tree limb snapped and its off to hell for you. Tell me, How are Thousands of Soldiers supposed to stick to a small road maybe about Ten Feet in Diameter.

There were minotaurs in Cyrodiil, and ogres, goblins, bears, wolves, mountain lions, trolls... Oh my. Funny how they won't an issue for entire Legions.
Did you read the extensive list of creatures other than minotaurs because there were quite a bit.

The Stormcloaks wouldn't even have issues from these creatures, they tend to leave entire armies alone. Small patrols could be attacked, but not a large force.
And where has this been said? I highly doubt a couple of Giant Snakes or Birds would wait for you to become a smaller force, but rather they would attack you while your all bunched up for easier pickings.

Yeah, and they weren't problems for armies on the move. Do you think the Imperial Legion has never patrolled or moved locations between provinces/new soldiers/supplies?

Why would this be a problem for the Legion now, when it never has been.
Because there are SO MANY of you. Then maybe a squad or two went missing, Now you're marching however many legions into Valenwood to attack the Bosmer who can morph into Hell Beasts at will, in full force. You clearly stated this would be a problem for the Stormcloaks but it won't be for the young unfamiliar Imperials. HOW? This is going to be a problem you will ALL DIE!! I'm saying cut your losses and invade Elsweyr only otherwise:

Borgas didn't have an army of enchanted Nord warriors, that was Ysgramor. Also the Wild Hunt, while it is a scary thing. It doesn't happen any time Valenwood is attacked or at war.
Why wouldn't he, They didn't hate/fear magic at that time they most likely would use it to their advantage. Also you quite clearly said they CAN use it at will.

Says who? Valenwood isn't the worst province for military engagements. Elswyer and Black Marsh are more annoying due to jungles and swamps.
Anyone who know's what the Bosmer can do says so!

The Imperial Legion in battle comes up with interesting ways of doing things. During the Second Era they marched under a lake, water breathing cast on the entire army. During Umbriel, they were imbued with flight and tried an air assault on the floating island.
Well I guess they're going to have to resurrect all their warriors after the attack in Valenwood because I'm quite certain that'll be the result.
 

Mikulas Black-Blade

The Cave Bear
Why do you think Ulfric had such little support in his cause over the Talos Ban when the Thalmor were only minor in Skyrim?
What do you mean by little support, He had a whole army backing him up ready to retake Markarth.
 
J

Jeremius

Guest
You do realize that a rebellion is nothing without a cause, right? The Thalmor are indirectly aiding the rebellion by being there to be the cause.

Have you listened to your own buddies in the rebellion?

Why is it worded the way it is? It makes no sense if it is to tell that the way simply needs to keep going. It makes sense if they are afraid of a united empire, which would also explain why they simply want to avoid the rebellion winning, rather than show any fear of them.

Well if that's true, by what you said, then the Thalmor are also indirectly aiding the Imperial Legion and the Empire by creating the Stormcloak rebellion in the first place by banning the worship of Talos. They gave the Thalmor what they want, and now the Thalmor is sitting back watching the dire consequences unraveled.

Yes I've listen to my buddies in the rebellion... Do you lend them your ear and listen to their plea? What their fighting for is legit.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000c348f

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000e1b22

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x0005b41d

It is real because it is there. And you refuse to acknowledge my point. Why is the mention of the Civil War in Ulfric's dossier written the way it is , with the Stormcloaks getting a tiny mention with no reason, while the Empire gets a reason why they should not win in the Thalmor's eyes?
 

Raijin

A Mage that loves a Templar
It won't happen, Empire is still in recovery. As someone who has been thru a very traumatic incident and went thru Recovery process afterwards, I assure you the Empire will be for many years trying to recover. It's not a sign of weakness, it doesn't mean it's a dead and "dying Empire", that's just life.

What you have to decide is one of two things. Either, you:

1) Have the faith to stand with the Empire in it's darkest hour

OR

2) Have lost faith in the Empire to the point where you feel that *any* alternative is better... NOT just Ulfric.

It seems that you want the situation to turn around to your standard and would like the Empire to meet your expectations. This is not reasonable because the Empire can't do this. You have to be willing to lay it all down for the Empire, <no matter> what shape she is in. Which is a hard thing to do.

Now, the other side of this discussion, is keep in mind the Thalmor WANT the Empire dead. When you consider the Empire in that light, well, that's all you really need to be an Imperial.

While the Empire is in recovery mode gives the Thalmor an equal amount of time to regain their strength and increase their power that they've lost in the Great war. Do you think that the Thalmor is just waiting for the Empire to be fully recovered? No.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000bc190

"There is peace now, and that peace will continue for as long as it suits our needs. But make no mistake, this is not a peace forged out of necessity between rival nations of equal strength. It is more like the calm between storms. And the next storm, I think, will be far deadlier than the last." - Ondolemar

According to Ondolemar the Thalmor doesn't want the Empire dead. If they truly wanted the Empire dead they would've executed the Emperor and took over Cyrodill during the Great war.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x0006477b

"The Empire exists because we allow it to exist, and I'm here to make sure the Jarl of Markarth remembers that." -Ondolemar

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x00041301

"There's no worse enemy to humankind in Tamriel. The Empire barely survived the last war. The Thalmor don't intend to lose the next one." -Delphine
 

Raijin

A Mage that loves a Templar
I'm just going to throw my newest findings in here.

Thongvor: "How goes the trade in and out of the city?"
Reburrus: "Very well, Thongvor. With the Stormcloaks here to help, the Silver-Blood family control nearly every route in and out of the city."
Yngvar: "Except the ones attacked by Forsworn."
Reburrus: "Well yes, of course you had to go and mention that."
Thongvor: "The Forsworn aren't our real concern, defeating the Imperials and making sure we keep control of this city is."
Reburrus: "Yes, Thongvor."

Thongvor: "Reburrus, I need you to draft a letter to Ulfric requesting more men."
Yngvar: "Ha! About time we got some more muscle in this city."
Reburrus: "Thongvor, do you really think that's wise? I mean, King Ulfric is such a busy man, and there are so many areas of Skyrim to protect."
Thongvor: "Whose side are you on, Reburrus? I'm not worried about Skyrim, I'm worried about the Reach. Specifically, the part of the Reach we're standing on."
Reburrus: "Yes, Thongvor. I'll draft the letter immediately."

It appears the Silver-Blood family is the Stormcloak-equivalent of the Blackbriar Family, only that the Blackbriars at least don't support a group of desperate people who in turn slaughter civilians.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x00098644

"Of course. Nothing gets done without my approval in this city. I have the Jarl's ear, and the guards in my pocket. Anyone makes trouble for me and I pay a visit to the Thieves Guild. Make me angry and I contact the Dark Brotherhood. You'd do well to remember that the next time you make such a stupid observation. " Maven Black-Briar

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000b8816


Hemming: "There's still the matter of the prisoner to discuss. Now, his family is willing to contribute handsomely if we release him."
Maven: "The execution will proceed as planned."
Hemming: "But, mother... this is quite a sizable contribution and the crime doesn't befit such a harsh punishment."
Maven: "Are you going soft on me, Hemming? Perhaps I made the wrong choice installing you as steward."
Hemming: "No, mother. The execution will proceed as planned."

Maven makes the Silver-Blood family look like generous and kind people.
 

Raijin

A Mage that loves a Templar
"We've been trying to catch Ulfric since the war started, but he always seemed to slip through our fingers... like he knew we were coming." - Hadvar

We know they've been trying to keep Ulfric alive.

Indirect aid, not direct aid. Financially supporting the rebellion would be direct aid, but their increased presence and strict enforcement of the Talos Ban is one of the key motivations of people joining Ulfric's rebellion. Listening to Stormcloak conversations at camps, they mention the Thalmor's actions recently are the reason some are under Ulfric's banner.

"When we destroy the rebellion, perhaps the Thalmor will call off their damned inquisitions. It's just making things worse." - Rikke

"I put in to be stationed here to keep an eye on the Thalmor. I've a feeling they're behind this unrest in Skyrim." - Fasendil

There is a lot of information that backs up the Dossier, looking for that smoking gun that will destroy why people should side with the Stormcloaks won't be found.

It is the reason many in this thread support the rebellion? The Thalmor going around arresting Talos worshipers, their recent increased presence is what many of you use in your arguments. The Thalmor are your big motivator, same with many Nords.

Why do you think Ulfric had such little support in his cause over the Talos Ban when the Thalmor were only minor in Skyrim?

Can we at least agree that the Stormcloaks and the Empire are the Thalmor's bitch? Both are doing exactly what the Thalmor wants.. to fight against each other, and guess what? General Tullius knew about this and done nothing to stop this. He kept on doing it up until his own life was threaten in defeat.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e18

"The Thalmor. They stirred up trouble here. Forced us to divert needed resources and throw away good soldiers quelling this rebellion." General Tullius

According to the database he suddenly became lucid, and forceful by disclosing this information with an intention of trying to reason his way of getting killed. Funny how he showed no mercy for the men whom hes sending off to be killed over this foolish war.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e16

"You realize this is exactly what they wanted." - General Tullius

General Warmongering Tullius should of thought of that before shipping his loyal men off to die.

The Empire made a huge mistake by giving this important assignment to someone who shows lack of remorse for other peoples lives but himself. Willing to stop acting like an idiot by weaseling himself out of being killed.

At least Emperor Titus Mede II didn't act like a cry baby when he was about to be killed, and he didn't weasel himself out from being killed too. I give the Empire that much credit. The reason why the Empire is so weak is that Titus Mede II is unable to find suitable people to help run the Empire.
 
J

Jeremius

Guest
Can we at least agree that the Stormcloaks and the Empire are the Thalmor's bitch? Both are doing exactly what the Thalmor wants.. to fight against each other, and guess what? General Tullius knew about this and done nothing to stop this. He kept on doing it up until his own life was threaten in defeat.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e18

"The Thalmor. They stirred up trouble here. Forced us to divert needed resources and throw away good soldiers quelling this rebellion." General Tullius

According to the database he suddenly became lucid, and forceful by disclosing this information with an intention of trying to reason his way of getting killed. Funny how he showed no mercy for the men whom hes sending off to be killed over this foolish war.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e16

"You realize this is exactly what they wanted." - General Tullius

General Warmongering Tullius should of thought of that before shipping his loyal men off to die.

The Empire made a huge mistake by giving this important assignment to someone who shows lack of remorse for other peoples lives but himself. Willing to stop acting like an idiot by weaseling himself out of being killed.

At least Emperor Titus Mede II didn't act like a cry baby when he was about to be killed, and he didn't weasel himself out from being killed too. I give the Empire that much credit. The reason why the Empire is so weak is that Titus Mede II is unable to find suitable people to help run the Empire.

And you cannot send a compassionate man to fight a war. Ruthless tactics are what is needed in war, not compassion and remorse. Showing remorse for sending loyal men to die is a weakness and failure of command.
 

Raijin

A Mage that loves a Templar
Can we at least agree that the Stormcloaks and the Empire are the Thalmor's bitch? Both are doing exactly what the Thalmor wants.. to fight against each other, and guess what? General Tullius knew about this and done nothing to stop this. He kept on doing it up until his own life was threaten in defeat.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e18

"The Thalmor. They stirred up trouble here. Forced us to divert needed resources and throw away good soldiers quelling this rebellion." General Tullius

According to the database he suddenly became lucid, and forceful by disclosing this information with an intention of trying to reason his way of getting killed. Funny how he showed no mercy for the men whom hes sending off to be killed over this foolish war.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e16

"You realize this is exactly what they wanted." - General Tullius

General Warmongering Tullius should of thought of that before shipping his loyal men off to die.

The Empire made a huge mistake by giving this important assignment to someone who shows lack of remorse for other peoples lives but himself. Willing to stop acting like an idiot by weaseling himself out of being killed.

At least Emperor Titus Mede II didn't act like a cry baby when he was about to be killed, and he didn't weasel himself out from being killed too. I give the Empire that much credit. The reason why the Empire is so weak is that Titus Mede II is unable to find suitable people to help run the Empire.

And you cannot send a compassionate man to fight a war. Ruthless tactics are what is needed in war, not compassion and remorse. Showing remorse for sending loyal men to die is a weakness and failure of command.

I strongly disagree with this logic. Without being a compassionate leader you're nothing more than a cold heart psychopathic thug who shouldn't even be leading an army in the first place. It is your sole duty as a leader to be concern for others.

The Imperial Soldiers aren't meat shields. They're human beings and elves. They entrusted you with their lives to do the right thing, and the least that you to cherish that great honor is to show compassion for them, and not to make stupid decisions that will cost them their lives like what General Tullius did. He allowed this war to continue... knowing that this is exactly what the Thalmor wanted. He even said it with his own words.
 
J

Jeremius

Guest
I strongly disagree with this logic. Without being a compassionate leader you're nothing more than a cold heart psychopathic thug who shouldn't even be leading an army in the first place. It is your sole duty as a leader to be concern for others.

The Imperial Soldiers aren't meat shields. They're human beings and elves. They entrusted you with their lives to do the right thing, and the least that you to cherish that great honor is to show compassion for them, and not to make stupid decisions that will cost them their lives like what General Tullius did. He allowed this war to continue... knowing that this is exactly what the Thalmor wanted. He even said it with his own words.

Tullius is a general in a war. The soldiers know what they are in for when they sign on. None of that requires Tullius to be a compassionate soul. If a soldier signs on expecting Tullius, whose only job is to win the Civil War, to be compassionate and concerned for him/her, then they are not worthy of being a soldier.
 

DrunkenMage

Intoxicated Arch-Mage
The Greybeards gave aid for war before. They constantly summon the Ash King and hes practically Unstoppable.

So common folk believe. Why didn't they do it during the Great War, or the Civil War or during the Oblivion Crisis?

Well like I said he finds that he's an old defenseless man who is quoted for suspicious acts and then he decides whether or not he can kill him.

Given Rimfaxe's quotes, it seems more likely the Penitus Oculatus wanted him to figure it out. What about the old man is suspicious, for him to observe, and carry out the kill.

So they kill you if you don't pass. Well that's fair.

Possibly. I'm not certain, but I wouldn't put it past them.

Doesn't mean they aren't going to organize ambushes, kill at night, be in general sneaky. The Stormcloaks, and Nords in general, excel at Raids.

Raids on forts, and established forces. Nords tend to fight open battles, entire armies smashing into each other.

Hammerfell isn't going to sit this war out. Morrowind seems okay, they're still recovering but if they have their quarrels with the Thalmor and The Empire.

I wouldn't even put it past Hammerfell invading Skyrim during their weakened state and taking some land from the Nords. That is the love between Hammerfell and Skyrim.

But do we know if they were using Materials from Valenwood or not. Its perfectly okay to build in Valenwood just so long as you don't harm the Forest.

http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:The_Green_Pact_and_the_Dominion

The Green pact applies to Wood Elves. They're not allowed to harm the forests, it is unclear if that applies to outsiders.

Let me repeat: the relationship between the Khajiit and the Empire was awful while the relationship between The Thalmor and the Khajiit is good. Relationship with the citizenry is important.

The current relationship is unknown, the Khajiit caravan leader in Skyrim hates the Thalmor. Some probably like them, some hate them.

No she isn't, not anymore at least. She's been dead for over six hundred years, I think whatever influence she had, fell away by now.
I suppose so, just throwing it out there.

As you know the Imperials are based off of the Romans so this should be the same or similar. I'm calling his tactics crap because they were literally just: Charge from all sides and hope we win the city back.

I believe the term is called 'Pincer Movement' which is a military tactic, and has been used in nearly every war. Such a crap tactic that it is taught even today to Military Officers.

The point of such a tactic is isolating and surrounding the enemy.

Also if you had any knowledge of Roman history, you'd know the Legions weren't always full. The book 'The Great War' mentions the Military weakness of the Empire, do you honestly believe they had full Legions? Some perhaps, but certainly not all.

Name Five and how many of them were Nords?

Battlemage Welloc

Archmage Geirmund

Archmage Shalidor

The Dragon Priests

All the Archmages in Sovngarde

In the Elder Scrolls it means a lot.

Games, perhaps.

In battle they separate what you're good at based on race. Hence why Jonna led a legion of mostly Nords so they could be the pushing power.

You got that from one sentence, out of a lot of lore surrounding the Legion. How come nothing backs up your claim on this?

General Jonna led mostly Nord Legions, why? Because they were from Skyrim. My god, Nords coming out of Skyrim, who'd have thought.

No but they separate based on what people are good at. and The Legions Jonna commanded were mostly Nords because most Nords are good at a similar thing. Force and Ferocity.

Or maybe the fact Jonna was the Legion General in Skyrim and the Legions from Skyrim were mostly made up of Nords. Let that sink in.

Well then that's different. Being Elven definitely means they have a head start. Of course they have a natural weakness to Magic.

Not anymore, in past games they did. But you're trying to use game stats to back up your argument. Funny how they tend to change every game, they dumb down the traits. Look at Morrowind, Oblivion and Skyrim, all the races. What is your theory on the changes? Is it forced evolution? Too much incest?

Again, it definitely gives you a head start, tell me, How many Bosmer warriors do you see on a daily basis.

In TESO, probably a lot.

Actually Redguards are naturally gifted and Nords are naturally resistant to Cold and Magical Frost as well as being Naturally Fierce in battle and Dunmer are naturally gifted in Destruction Magic as well as being immune to Fire The List goes on Drunken these are not stats this is in-game and out of game Lore.

Is it? Can you show me where all of this happens in lore? In the various books, journals and such. The games keep changing the stats, so next game you may have an even smaller resist frost on Nords or like the recent change from Oblivion, Nords being skilled in different skill trees. They were heavy armor last game.

Oh yeah it was attacked before and it was pretty grizzly for the attacking side.

Like?

After an entire war only NOW does he know where Nords go when they die.

Do you know where Imperials go? Or Altmer? You've fought a war against the Legion, killed many Imperials, you've killed many Thalmor. Yet... Can you answer to me where they go when they die?

Well then why didn't they just destroy the White Gold Tower while they had it for 30 days

Because hidden magical things just show themselves. It would probably take some time to figure out how to destroy it. Or maybe they need to deactivate the last tower first.

I honestly don't know, the thing doesn't exactly come with a "How to" instruction book. There isn't a "Don't press this button or world ends".

You're invading them, good luck.
And good luck with yours, hope they don't kill you to gruesomely. At least a Fire Explosion Spell is a relatively quick death.

Well then boo on him, that was Tiber Septim the man, I worship Talos, Ysmir, The Dragon of the North.

You don't even know what Talos is.

What are you saying. I'm saying Ulfric wasn't a Legate and your over there talking about how Ulfric was captured before the Imperial city fell.

I never called Ulfric a Legate? So where are you even getting that. Legions from Skyrim were being sent to Cyrodiil throughout the war. Not just when Jonna arrived.

And he didn't foresee them. Y'know for a the great tactician Titus claims to be its hard to believe he just wouldn't know there were Soldiers camped in Bravil and Skingrad.

He probably did know, the point of soldiers is to fight. Nords saw battle, some died and went to Sovngarde. What is your point? Did you think there would be no resistance from the Aldmeri when Titus II was trying to cut off the main army and surround them?

Basilisks might be a problem. how about Griffons, Werevultures.

They can have a ballista bolt to the face.

Who's to say there will be one random creature, How about ten or twenty how well are you going to fight against 20 griffons or twenty Basilisks.

They go in packs? Source? Oh wait, never mind.

Well you best use those to the best of your ability, because one tree limb snapped and its off to hell for you. Tell me, How are Thousands of Soldiers supposed to stick to a small road maybe about Ten Feet in Diameter.

People break tree branches and step on plants all the time in Valenwood.

Did you read the extensive list of creatures other than minotaurs because there were quite a bit.

Yeah, but do they all move together? Are they known to attack armies?

And where has this been said? I highly doubt a couple of Giant Snakes or Birds would wait for you to become a smaller force, but rather they would attack you while your all bunched up for easier pickings.

Where has this been said? No where, which is my point. If these creatures attack military forces, why is it not documented? Not even in TESO, unless you can correct me.

Because there are SO MANY of you.

Strength in numbers.

Then maybe a squad or two went missing, Now you're marching however many legions into Valenwood to attack the Bosmer who can morph into Hell Beasts at will, in full force.

Except they can't turn back. It requires a ritual, whcih they haven't used in god knows how long. Not even during the Alliance Wars.

You clearly stated this would be a problem for the Stormcloaks but it won't be for the young unfamiliar Imperials. HOW?

Because I'm biased obviously. When I'm not quoting lore text, I have that Imperial favored agenda. Perhaps the signature wasn't a good enough hint?

This is going to be a problem you will ALL DIE!!

It's all doom and gloom with you.


Why wouldn't he, They didn't hate/fear magic at that time they most likely would use it to their advantage. Also you quite clearly said they CAN use it at will.

Because it isn't mentioned. You can't just have an army of enchanted warriors without it telling you so. Ysgramor's 500 had powerful enchantments. But it doesn't make every Nordic army have it.

They can use it, but they do it rarely.

Anyone who know's what the Bosmer can do says so!

You lot didn't even know what a Wild Hunt was several debates ago, are you now experts?

Well I guess they're going to have to resurrect all their warriors after the attack in Valenwood because I'm quite certain that'll be the result.

It's a good thing Necromancy is legal, and we have many Necromancers in the Empire.

What do you mean by little support, He had a whole army backing him up ready to retake Markarth.

Then why isn't he High King? He's had Stormcloaks fighting for years, yet the Legion only stepped in a few months ago. He didn't have a whole army, he had a militia who answered Jarl Hrolfdir's call. He was just leading the attack, it didn't make it his.

The Empire made a huge mistake by giving this important assignment to someone who shows lack of remorse for other peoples lives but himself. Willing to stop acting like an idiot by weaseling himself out of being killed.

"Guards! Get the townspeople to safety!"

For someone who doesn't care about anyone except himself, that is an interesting order to give? Funny, where was that lack of remorse of peoples lives when Alduin was attacking.

At least Emperor Titus Mede II didn't act like a cry baby when he was about to be killed, and he didn't weasel himself out from being killed too. I give the Empire that much credit. The reason why the Empire is so weak is that Titus Mede II is unable to find suitable people to help run the Empire.

Tullius didn't cry, he didn't beg or try to 'weasel' himself out of being killed. In fact, General Tullius faced his death well, he merely says "So be it" when told he's to be killed then and there.
 

DrunkenMage

Intoxicated Arch-Mage
He allowed this war to continue... knowing that this is exactly what the Thalmor wanted. He even said it with his own words.

Tullius knows the Thalmor are behind the Civil War, what does that change?

Ulfric is still in arms against the Empire, thousands of citizens loyal to the Empire are still being threatened by the Stormcloak rebellion. Should Tullius just hand Skyrim over to Ulfric because he's so stupid that he can't even see he's being used?

Is that your solution? Give Ulfric and the Stormcloaks Skyrim, because they're too thick and unable to see the big picture? Abandon thousands who do not want Ulfric as their ruler?

Why does that make Tullius bad? It is Ulfric and Galmar who are twenty steps behind the Thalmor. I don't think Ulfric should be rewarded because he's an idiot and his cause is short sighted.

You seem to also believe that had Tullius gave this knowledge to Ulfric, he would stop his fighting. When Ulfric is informed, why doesn't he stop? He kills Tullius and commands that the remaining Legionnaires hidden in Skyrim be hunted down. May just be me, but isn't that the opposite of what you said would happen?
 

Rimfaxe96

Well-Known Member
Maven makes the Silver-Blood family look like generous and kind people.

How? Maven even though she's no Jarl practically already runs the city; the Silver-Bloods might not have that much influence on the Jarl, but almost every land, business or property in the Reach is owned/influenced by them.
She has the Thieves Guild in her pocket? The Silver-Bloods will send their thugs if you start any trouble. And anyone capable of doing the Black Sacrament can contact the Dark Brotherhood, so that's no argument either.
 

Raijin

A Mage that loves a Templar
Tullius is a general in a war. The soldiers know what they are in for when they sign on. None of that requires Tullius to be a compassionate soul. If a soldier signs on expecting Tullius, whose only job is to win the Civil War, to be compassionate and concerned for him/her, then they are not worthy of being a soldier.

Just because they signed on doesn't make it right for their General to make piss poor life and death decisions. General Tullius was indirectly aiding the Thalmor by sending his troops to die. He even confessed to it.

I'll remind you again what General Tullius said

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e18

The Thalmor. They stirred up trouble here. Forced us to divert needed resources and throw away good soldiers quelling this rebellion.

http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e16

You realize this is exactly what they wanted.
 

Raijin

A Mage that loves a Templar
"Guards! Get the townspeople to safety!"

For someone who doesn't care about anyone except himself, that is an interesting order to give? Funny, where was that lack of remorse of peoples lives when Alduin was attacking.

Tullius didn't cry, he didn't beg or try to 'weasel' himself out of being killed. In fact, General Tullius faced his death well, he merely says "So be it" when told he's to be killed then and there.

Oh that's a natural response for a catastrophic event, and yes. Your warmongering General did try to weasel himself out of being killed when he started saying "And if I surrender?" http://cs.uesp.net/index.php?game=sr&formid=0x000d1e04

He begged the Stormcloaks to spare his life.
 

Raijin

A Mage that loves a Templar
Tullius knows the Thalmor are behind the Civil War, what does that change?

Ulfric is still in arms against the Empire, thousands of citizens loyal to the Empire are still being threatened by the Stormcloak rebellion. Should Tullius just hand Skyrim over to Ulfric because he's so stupid that he can't even see he's being used?

Is that your solution? Give Ulfric and the Stormcloaks Skyrim, because they're too thick and unable to see the big picture? Abandon thousands who do not want Ulfric as their ruler?

Why does that make Tullius bad? It is Ulfric and Galmar who are twenty steps behind the Thalmor. I don't think Ulfric should be rewarded because he's an idiot and his cause is short sighted.

You seem to also believe that had Tullius gave this knowledge to Ulfric, he would stop his fighting. When Ulfric is informed, why doesn't he stop? He kills Tullius and commands that the remaining Legionnaires hidden in Skyrim be hunted down. May just be me, but isn't that the opposite of what you said would happen?

So you admit that Tullius knew that the Thalmor was behind this civil war... What does he do? He kept on giving entertainment to his elven masters. He indirectly provided aid by pissing away much resources to deal with the Stormcloak rebellion.

Yes my solution is to give Skyrim to Ulfric but must sign an agreement to become allies of the Empire, and must provide aid to them in the incoming Great war. If Ulfric breaks the agreement at any given time the Empire would be allowed to retake Skyrim, and Ulfric would forcefully be dethroned. I think it's a fair trade. This would benefit a lot of people, even the Empire. This would null the the white gold concordat, and the remaining units of the Thalmor would be chased out of Skyrim, and Talos worship would open again. How is that bad?

If Tullius provided Ulfric with such valuable information, and pleaded with him to end the war, and was ignored... then I would sympathized with Tullius that much, and my respect for Ulfric would cease to exist.
 

Recent chat visitors

Latest posts

Top